How California Lemon Law Protects Buyers
When your supposedly new vehicle turns into a headache, you might ask: What is lemon law? California’s Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, commonly called the lemon law, requires manufacturers to honor their warranties. Under Civil Code § 1793.2(d), if a manufacturer or its representative can’t repair a new motor vehicle after a reasonable number of attempts, it must replace the vehicle or refund the purchase price. Consumers can learn more about their rights under California lemon law claims.
The statutory buyback includes a refund of the down payment, monthly payments, and payoff of the loan. The manufacturer may deduct only a mileage offset calculated as the purchase price multiplied by miles driven before the first repair attempt, divided by 120,000, per the statute’s formula, and certain optional purchased items.
The lemon law ensures that warranties are enforceable, not just marketing. It requires manufacturers to maintain repair facilities and fix defects covered under warranty. If repairs fail, they must offer a replacement or repurchase the vehicle, and importantly, the buyer can refuse a replacement and insist on a repurchase.
Owners can also recover incidental damages like towing and rentals.
Section 1794 strengthens these protections. If the violation is willful, courts can impose a civil penalty up to twice actual damages, and manufacturers must cover attorneys’ fees and court costs.
Case Study: Niedermeier v. FCA US LLC
Lisa Niedermeier bought a new Jeep Wrangler for about $40,000. It soon developed transmission, engine, and exhaust problems, jerking, rattling, grinding, and noxious gases. She returned the Jeep 16 times over four years; it was out of service for 75 days. She asked FCA to repurchase it, but they refused. Eventually, she traded it for a GMC Yukon and received a $19,000 trade-in credit, then filed suit.
The Legal Issue and Ruling
The Supreme Court considered whether a manufacturer can reduce restitution under the lemon law by the value of a consumer’s trade-in when the manufacturer refused to repurchase the defective vehicle. The Court ruled no. According to §1793.2(d), restitution equals the price paid, minus only the mileage deduction.
Therefore, trade-in credits don’t reduce the refund. Allowing such offsets, the Court reasoned, would reward manufacturers for delay.
The Outcome
The jury awarded:
- $39,799 for the purchase price (less a $5,214.57 mileage deduction)
- $5,000 in incidental damages
- $59,376.65 in civil penalties due to FCA’s willful conduct
FCA’s argument that the $19,000 trade-in should reduce the award was rejected.
Buyer Pitfalls and Common Misconceptions
- “As-is” sales don’t eliminate responsibility if the dealer gave an express warranty or misrepresented the car.
- Service contracts are not the same as warranties; they don’t relieve the manufacturer of legal obligations.
- Express warranties are written promises to fix defects. Implied warranties arise automatically and guarantee basic functionality. The mileage deduction applies only to express warranty claims.
To preserve your rights:
- Document every repair visit.
- Keep all repair orders, receipts, and communications.
- Submit buyback requests in writing.
- If you trade in or sell the car due to the manufacturer’s refusal, the Niedermeier case confirms you still qualify for full restitution.
FAQs About Lemon Law
What if someone else crashes my car?
If someone else drives your lemon and gets into an accident, your insurance will typically provide primary coverage. Their policy may offer secondary coverage. This doesn’t affect your lemon law rights, but it doesn’t relieve you of keeping valid insurance.
Is it illegal to drive without insurance in California?
Yes. Vehicle Code §16028 requires all drivers to carry and show proof of insurance when requested by law enforcement, even if you’re driving a loaner while your lemon is being repaired.
How many repair attempts count as “reasonable”?
There’s no fixed number. But four failed attempts or 30 total days out of service create a legal presumption that the vehicle qualifies as a lemon. Fewer attempts may suffice for serious safety defects.
When to Seek Legal Help
Lemon law offers strong protections, but manufacturers may push back. They may:
- Deny that the defect is significant
- Blame you for the issue
- Try to deduct trade-in value despite the Niedermeier ruling
If your car has ongoing issues and the dealer refuses to buy it back, it’s time to consult an attorney. Many consumers searching for “what is lemon law” learn that legal help is often essential. Some situations may also involve auto dealer fraud claims when defects or vehicle history are misrepresented.
Contact Auto Law Firm, PC
At Auto Law Firm, PC, we’ve helped many clients handle lemon law and auto fraud claims. We document problems, negotiate with manufacturers, and go to court when necessary. You deserve clear answers, not legal jargon.
📞 619-975-5802
🏢 500 La Terraza Blvd., Suite 150, Escondido, CA 92025
📍 San Diego Office
🔗 Schedule your consultation today